Selling the Season: Your Guide to Pumpkin Spice Bellavitano

Cheese Details

  • Cheese Name: Pumpkin Spice Bellavitano
  • Producer/Brand: Sartori
  • Country/Region of Origin: USA / Plymouth, Wisconsin
  • Milk Type & Treatment: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
  • A2 Dominant: Not Specified
  • Cheese Style: American Original Hard Cheese (Cheddar/Parmesan Hybrid) with Spiced Rind
  • Aging: Aged for several months (the base cheese is typically aged 10-12 months)

Introduction

Welcome to your essential guide for one of the most talked-about cheeses of the fall season: Sartori's Pumpkin Spice Bellavitano. This cheese presents a unique opportunity at the counter. The name itself can be polarizing, often conjuring images of overly sweet coffee drinks.1 This guide is designed to empower you to turn that potential hesitation into an enthusiastic sale. We will shift the narrative from a simple "flavored cheese" to what it truly is: a masterfully crafted, award-winning American original that has been thoughtfully finished with a blend of warm, aromatic autumn spices. By leading with the exceptional quality of the cheese itself, you can guide customers on a journey of discovery, proving that this seasonal specialty is a sophisticated, savory delight worthy of a place on any holiday cheese board.

The Quick Pitch

Elevator Pitch

This is a seasonal twist on Sartori's world-champion BellaVitano cheese. It's a creamy, nutty cheese—like a cross between a great cheddar and parmesan—that's hand-rubbed with warm autumn spices like cinnamon and nutmeg for a perfect savory-and-spiced holiday flavor. It's not sweet like a latte; it's a sophisticated savory cheese perfect for the season.

Key Selling Points

  • Built on a Champion: This cheese starts with the legendary BellaVitano Gold, an American Original that has won prestigious awards globally, including "Best New Cheese in the World" and "Grand Champion" at the U.S. Cheese Championship.3 You're selling a world-class cheese first, with a seasonal finish.
  • Subtle & Savory, Not Sweet: The "pumpkin spice" is a delicate, warming blend that complements, rather than overpowers, the cheese. Customer feedback consistently highlights that it offers a savory experience with just a "hint of sweet earthiness"—nothing like a sugary drink.1
  • The Perfect Holiday Headliner: Its unique flavor, festive aroma, and seasonal nature make it a standout star on any Thanksgiving, Friendsgiving, or holiday cheese board. Its limited availability creates a sense of urgency and makes it a special find for customers.1
  • An Edible, Flavorful Rind: The hand-rubbed spices on the rind are meant to be eaten and are an integral part of the experience. Be sure to tell customers that every bite, from the center to the edge, is packed with flavor.7

"If you like X, you'll love this"

  • Spiced Goudas: Customers familiar with Dutch Goudas that incorporate savory spices like clove or nutmeg will immediately understand and appreciate this concept.8
  • Sartori's Espresso or Black Pepper Bellavitano: For customers who already love other bold BellaVitano flavors, this is an easy and exciting next step. It's part of a celebrated line of innovative, hand-rubbed flavor finishes.10

Tasting & Sensory Profile

This is a "must-sample" cheese. The experience of tasting it is the most effective tool for overcoming preconceptions.1 Guide the customer through this sensory journey.

  • Appearance: The paste is a beautiful, creamy, pale-yellow, consistent with the classic BellaVitano.12 The exterior rind is a rustic, autumnal brown, visibly coated in a delicate blend of ground spices, making it visually appealing on a cheese board.
  • Aroma: The primary scent is of warm, aromatic baking spices—cinnamon and nutmeg are most prominent—layered over the nutty, savory, and slightly fruity aroma of the base cheese.1 It smells like autumn in a cheese shop.
  • Flavor Profile: The taste journey is key to the sale. It begins with the familiar, beloved flavors of the BellaVitano base: savory, nutty, and buttery, with hints of fruit.12 As it warms on the palate, the subtle, warming spice notes emerge. Emphasize that it is a savory spice profile, not a sweet one. The finish is balanced and lingering, where the creamy butteriness of the cheese and the warmth of the spices coexist beautifully.
  • Texture & Mouthfeel: The paste is firm yet creamy and rich. The signature "crystalline crunch" from naturally occurring calcium lactate crystals provides a delightful textural contrast that customers love—assure them this is a desirable sign of a well-aged cheese.12 The spice rub on the rind adds a very fine, pleasant texture that enhances the overall mouthfeel.

The Story & Interesting Facts

Selling a cheese is selling a story. Sartori provides a fantastic one.

Sartori is a fourth-generation family-owned company founded in 1939 in Plymouth, Wisconsin, by Italian immigrant Paolo Sartori.4 They have built a legacy on combining Italian cheesemaking traditions with American ingenuity. The milk for this cheese comes from local, family-owned farms, often turned into cheese within hours of arrival, reflecting a deep commitment to quality and community.12

The BellaVitano itself is a true American Original, introduced in 2008 after years of experimentation by Sartori's Master Cheesemakers.4 It was intentionally designed to be the "marriage of a creamy cheddar and a premium farmstead parmesan".12 This Pumpkin Spice version takes a wheel of that award-winning cheese and hand-rubs the rind with a proprietary blend of spices, a process done in their historic East Main Caves.4 It's a vegetarian cheese, made using microbial (non-animal) rennet, making it accessible to more customers.7

Pairings & Culinary Uses

Help customers imagine this cheese in their homes to drive larger sales.

Perfect Food Pairings

  • Sweet: Sliced Honeycrisp apples, Bosc pears, fig jam, pumpkin butter, candied pecans, dried cranberries, a drizzle of maple syrup.19
  • Savory: Prosciutto, smoked turkey, toasted hazelnuts or almonds, roasted pumpkin seeds.11
  • Carrier (crackers, bread, etc.): Toasted baguette slices, rosemary-forward crackers, cinnamon pita chips, or even gingersnaps for a more dessert-like pairing.1

Beverage Pairings

  • Wine: Off-dry Riesling, Gewürztraminer, a light-bodied Pinot Noir, or a buttery Chardonnay.22
  • Beer: Pumpkin Ale, a malty Brown Ale or Oktoberfest/Märzen, or a rich Stout or Porter.24
  • Other: Crisp hard apple cider, spiced chai tea, or a bourbon-based cocktail like an Old Fashioned.9

In the Kitchen

  • Gourmet Grilled Cheese: Layer with prosciutto and apple butter on sourdough for an unforgettable sandwich.1
  • Elevated Pasta: Shave it over butternut squash risotto or a simple sage and brown butter pasta.
  • Fall Salads: Crumble into a harvest salad with kale, roasted squash, and a maple vinaigrette.
  • Savory Baking: Grate it into a savory scone or biscuit recipe to add a unique holiday flair.

Cheesemonger Quick Guide

Your cheat sheet for a busy Saturday at the counter.

  • Evocative Words: Warm-spiced, Autumnal, Nutty, Creamy, Savory, Buttery, Subtle, Aromatic, Festive, Unique.
  • Sample Phrases to Use with Customers:
    • "Don't let the name fool you—it's wonderfully savory and complex, not sweet like a coffee drink. Here, have a taste!"
    • "This is our headliner for Thanksgiving cheese boards. It pairs beautifully with apples, prosciutto, and a glass of cider or a malty beer."
    • "This starts with Sartori's most award-winning cheese, a cheddar-parmesan hybrid, and then they rub it with warming autumn spices. The quality is incredible."

Works cited

  1. Can't imagine why this pumpkin spice cheese isn't selling well - Reddit, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Cheese/comments/1ciu3d0/cant_imagine_why_this_pumpkin_spice_cheese_isnt/
  2. Sometimes pumpkin spice goes too far : r/wisconsin - Reddit, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/wisconsin/comments/16zs10r/sometimes_pumpkin_spice_goes_too_far/
  3. Sartori Bourbon BellaVitano - a snackable bourbon-washed cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.murrayscheese.com/dp/sartori-bourbon-bellavitano
  4. Our Heritage - Sartori Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/our-story/heritage/
  5. Leading With Legacy | Wisconsin Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.wisconsincheese.com/the-cheese-life/article/202/leading-with-legacy
  6. Im addicted to this stuff (sartori merlot bellavitano) : r/Cheese - Reddit, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Cheese/comments/e0rt9q/im_addicted_to_this_stuff_sartori_merlot/
  7. Sartori BellaVitano® Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/our-cheese/bellavitano/
  8. 8 Pumpkin-Themed Cheeses to Serve this Halloween | culture: the word on cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://culturecheesemag.com/blog/pumpkin-spice-cheese/
  9. Pumpkin Spice—Not Latte—Gouda - Boise Co-op, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.boise.coop/blog-recipes-1/pumpkin-spice-not-latte-gouda
  10. BellaVitano - Sartori Cheese Shop, accessed September 6, 2025, https://shop.sartoricheese.com/collections/bellavitano
  11. Pair by Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/pairing/cheese/
  12. Sartori BellaVitano | Wisconsin Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.wisconsincheese.com/about-cheese/sartori-bellavitano
  13. BellaVitano Gold Cheese Review - Cheese a Week #1 - Savory and Sour Test Kitchen, accessed September 6, 2025, https://savoryandsour.com/2017/08/22/cheese-week-1-bellavitano-gold/
  14. Sartori FAQs, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/faq/
  15. Curd Is the Word: Storage & Enjoyment Best Practices for Sartori Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/news-articles/articles/curd-is-the-word/
  16. Sartori Cheese: A cultured heritage | by Marquette University, accessed September 6, 2025, https://stories.marquette.edu/sartori-cheese-a-cultured-heritage-6a58d2dc1e68
  17. BellaVitano: A Most Versatile Cheese from Wisconsin, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.cheeseprofessor.com/blog/bellavitano-wisconsin
  18. Sartori Cheese: World-Class Parmesan from Wisconsin, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.wisconsincheeseman.com/blog/cheese-nation/sartori-world-class-parmesan-cheese/
  19. Pumpkin Spice & October Cheese Pairings, accessed September 6, 2025, https://cheeseandmeatclub.com/blogs/cheese-and-charcuterie-blog/pumpkin-spice-cheese-pairings-october
  20. Pumpkin Maple Cheese Board - Blake Hill Preserves, accessed September 6, 2025, https://blakehillpreserves.com/blogs/recipes/pumpkin-maple-cheese-board
  21. Pair By Food - Sartori Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.sartoricheese.com/pairing/food/
  22. Wine Pairings in The Fall Season - Elegant Image Limousine, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.elegantimagelimos.com/news/2023/10/23/wine-pairings-in-the-fall-season
  23. ​Wine and Pumpkin Pairings: Does It Work? | Latah Creek Wine Cellars, accessed September 6, 2025, https://latahcreek.com/news/wine-and-pumpkin-pairings-does-it-work/
  24. How To Create Autumnal Cheese Pairings, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.wisconsincheese.com/the-cheese-life/article/150/autumn-cheese-pairings
  25. 4 Must-Try Beer Pairings for This Fall | Wisconsin Cheese, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.wisconsincheese.com/the-cheese-life/article/146/fall-beer-pairings
  26. The best food pairings for Pumpkin Ales - Baladin, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.baladin.it/en/blog/the-best-food-pairings-for-pumpkin-ales
  27. 3 Creative Ways to Style Bella Vitano Merlot Cheese - TikTok, accessed September 6, 2025, https://www.tiktok.com/@chscoastalcharcuterie/video/7134699129996987691